The Boy Scouts voted to allow openly gay Scouts but only until they’re 18, and still keep the ban on openly gay leaders.
The decision, which came after years of resistance and wrenching internal debate, was widely seen as a milestone for the Boy Scouts, a symbol of traditional America. More than 1,400 volunteer leaders from across the country voted, with more than 60 percent approving a measure that said no youth may be denied membership “on the basis of sexual orientation or preference alone.”
The top national leaders of the Boy Scouts, who pledge fealty to God and country, had urged the change in the face of vehement opposition from conservative parents and volunteers, some of whom said they would quit the organization. But the vote put the Scouts more in line with the swift rise in public acceptance of homosexuality, especially among younger parents who are essential to the future of an institution that has been losing members for decades.
The policy change, effective January 2014, is unlikely to bring peace to the Boy Scouts as they struggle to keep a foothold in a swirling cultural landscape, with renewed lobbying and debate already starting Thursday evening.
The Scouts did not consider the even more divisive question of whether to allow openly gay adults and leaders. This drew criticism from advocates for gay rights, who called the decision a breakthrough but vowed to continue pressing the Scouts to allow gay members of all ages.
A number of churches such as the Southern Baptists and Catholic dioceses that sponsor Scout troops say they will drop out now that openly gay boys are allowed in. Good. There’s the door. Kids don’t need to be around bigots, and if they believe that’s part of Scouting, they’re teaching the wrong values.
The halfway measure — allowing gay Scouts but not leaders — and the logic behind it reminds me of the ill-fated Don’t Ask Don’t Tell in the military. It’s designed to open the closet door only a little bit and placate the folks who think that just because an adult is openly gay he’s going to hit on children. It plays to the prejudice and homophobia that breeds among the sex-obsessed blue noses. They’re the ones to worry about.