Thursday, August 15, 2013


Josh Marshall makes the case that it’s pointless to go after Sen. Ted Cruz (R-TX) over the question of whether or not he’s eligible to run for president: the law is pretty clear that he’s a natural-born U.S. citizen.

Yes, it’s nice to see Tea Partiers discomfited that their guy really was born outside the United States (he was born in Calgary). But that schadenfreude doesn’t change the fact that he’s natural born and thus eligible. As he told ABC News a month ago, “My mother was born in Wilmington, Delaware. She’s a U.S. citizen, so I’m a U.S. citizen … “I can tell you where I was born and who my parents were.” And he’s right. That settles it.

By every historical and legal standard, “natural born” in the Constitution simply means that you were born an American citizen. The fact of your birth made you an American citizen.

It is well-established that being born on American soil makes you an American citizen. And being born to an American citizen, no matter where you were born, makes you an American citizen. At the time of his birth, Cruz was born to a mother who was an American citizen. That clinches it. The fact that his father was then not yet an American citizen is not relevant. Just as the location of Cruz’s own birth is not relevant. The Congressional Research Service actually did a study of this a couple years ago and after lengthy research and documentation, they basically came up with what I said above.

Over the last half dozen years, in addition to coming up with numerous conspiracy theories that allege specific factual inaccuracies about President Obama’s birth, the ‘birther’ community has developed all sorts of harebrained interpretations of what ‘natural born’ mean. They’re all wrong. It simply means, did you become an American citizen by the fact of your birth – whether that mean your parentage or geography?

Still thinking of pressing this point? Nope. Zip it. It’s done.

The only reason I’ve ever brought it up in the past was to tweak the noses of the birthers who have been using President Obama’s birth certificate as a thin veil for their racism.  And if they keep insisting on bringing it up when Mr. Cruz runs — and he will — then it will be fun to hear them pretzelize themselves to explain how “that’s different!”  Yeah, how?

The other reason Mr. Cruz’s circumstances of birth are pointless is because of the simple fact that it will not matter.  He will never be elected President of the United States, so it’s a waste of time to think about it.

7 barks and woofs on “Stillbirth

  1. He will never be elected President of the United States

    Never underestimate the potential of a gullible, manipulated electorate to sElect the worst possible candidate for public office. Recall the election that gave us Gov. Voldemort, who conveniently spelled out his entire agenda up front – which the Teahad voraciously lapped up until the effects began becoming obvious even to them.

  2. So what happens if Mustang Bobby visits a sperm bank. The bank gets a request for some seed from New Zealand.

    Are the kids generated from this transaction US citizens?

  3. No, because the rules are bit more complicated when it comes to the father. Read the follow-up post at TPM.

    And the chances of Mustang Bobby going to a sperm bank are about as likely as a snake riding a bicycle.

    • [cough] [snort] [giggle]

      I think A100 thinks you’re really Pandora Boxx. Though it wouldn’t help in that case, either.

  4. I thought that individuals born outside the U.S. would be considered U.S. citizens if the parents were U.S. citizens (or at least one) and they were born in U.S. territory, like a military base or a U.S. possession like Guam, etc.

Comments are closed.