Wednesday, November 10, 2021


We’re getting closer to getting the evidence.  Via TPM:

The ruling out tonight from US District Judge Tanya Chutkan is a big one. The decision can and certainly will be appealed. Trump actually tried to appeal the decision in advance of it even coming out. But Chutkan’s ruling vindicates the principle – long assumed and all but inevitable in the logic of the constitution and the office of the presidency it creates – that decisions about executive privilege inhere in the office and thus the current occupant of the office. Which is to say, Joe Biden.

As Chutkan puts it succintly: “Presidents are not kings, and Plaintiff is not President.”

Josh Kovensky has more details and analysis of the ruling here. I recommend his piece to you. But the key is her finding that since the Executive branch and Congress are in full agreement about what should happen, that really settles it – “the combined will of the legislative and executive branches to study the events that led to and occurred on Jan 6…” There’s no dispute between any parties with any standing to dispute anything. The National Archives must begin producing the documents by Friday.

Trump is just a private citizen who used to have the powers exercised today by Joe Biden. Elections have consequences.

As noted, the battle will be continued in appeal, probably dragging out to next summer, but it’s inevitable that at some point the committee will get them.

There’s another fight brewing: the subpoenas are piling up on the doorsteps of the Trump minions.  They’ll fight those, too, which means more court battles and delays.  But it’s going to happen.

2 barks and woofs on “Wham

  1. I think he’s biding his time, waiting to see if the rest of the gang decides to defy the subpoenas, so he can be consistent in how he deals with them. I also think there’s some merit in the argument that indicting in haste could be to his disadvantage.


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *